The first team to win three competitions would get to keep the trophy.
St. Dunstan's finally won for the third time in 1939.
- 1934-35: Prince of Wales
- 1935-36: St. Dunstan's
- 1936-37: Prince of Wales
- 1937-38: St. Dunstan's
- 1938-39: St. Dunstan's
Photos courtesy Simon Lloyd, University Archivist, University of Prince Edward Island.