The All-Atlantic Hockey Teams are composed of players at all positions from teams that are members of the Atlantic Hockey Association, a NCAADivision Ihockey-only conference. Each year, at the conclusion of the Atlantic Hockey regular season, the head coaches of each member team vote for players to be placed on each all-conference team. The First Team, Second Team and Rookie Teams have been named since 2003-04 (the inaugural year of Atlantic Hockey) and a Third Team was added starting in 2006-07.
The all-conference teams are composed of one goaltender, two defencemen and three forwards. Should a tie occur for the final selection at any position, both players will be included as part of the superior team with no reduction in the number of players appearing on any succeeding teams (as happened in 2004-05 and 2008-09). Players may only appear once per year on any of the first, second, or third teams but freshman may appear on both the rookie team and one of the other all-conference teams.