The Jinelle Siergiej Award was introduced in 2011. The criteria for the award is the "Overall Offensive Player of the Year". The award is presented to a female ice hockey player from Wisconsin prep school and coaches are asked to nominate a player from their respective team.
|2011||Alice Cranston ||St. Croix Valley Fusion|
|2012||Theresa Knutson||Onalaska Hilltoppers|
|2013||Theresa Knutson||Onalaska Hilltoppers|
|2014||Theresa Knutson||Onalaska Hilltoppers|
|2015||Nicole Unsworth||University School of Milwaukee Wildcats|
|2016||Nicole Unsworth||University School of Milwaukee Wildcats|